Skip to main content Scroll Top
2487 Cedarcreast Road, Suite 711, Acworth, GA 30101

The Economics of Retention — What Dealers Are Leaving on the Table

Part 2 of the NexGen™ Retention Series: “The Power of Relationships That Create Retention and Drive Revenue.”

The Missed Opportunity Hiding in Plain Sight
What if every customer who walked out your door after their first oil change quietly took $5,000 with them?

Dealers spend thousands of dollars per vehicle to earn a sale. But for many stores, the lifetime value of that customer slips away in the first 12 months of ownership.

According to Cox Automotive (2023), dealership share of service visits has fallen from 35% in 2021 to just 30% in 2023.

The irony? Most of those customers report being satisfied with the sales experience.  Satisfaction isn’t loyalty — and retention is where the money is.

Part 2 of the NexGen Retention Series: “The Power of Relationships That Create Retention and Drive Revenue.” by N2 Plus

The True Value of a Retained Customer
A truly loyal customer is worth far more than the gross profit from the sale.

A retained customer typically delivers:

  • $2,500–$3,000 per year in service, maintenance, and parts
  • Higher accessory and protection product adoption
  • 2.5× greater likelihood of buying their next vehicle from the same dealership

Bain & Company: A 5% increase in customer retention can boost profits by 25–95%.

The Cost of Defection
When a customer leaves after year one, the loss isn’t a missed oil change — it cascades across years.

Each lost customer typically costs a dealership:

  • $300–$500 in short-term service revenue
  • 3–5 years of maintenance and repair work
  • The next vehicle sale in the household
  • The ‘second car’ opportunity (1.85 vehicles per household)

Every defection is a two-car loss — the one they own today and the one they’ll buy tomorrow.

The Hidden ROI of the Service Connection
Dealers who create a structured introduction to Service see measurable improvements:

  • 30–40% higher first-visit retention
  • 1.5× more repair orders per customer
  • Higher engagement from the second household vehicle
  • Greater trust → more repeat sales

Retention → Service → Trust → Repeat Sales → More Retention

Retention Isn’t a Metric — It’s a Business Model
Retention must be treated not as a KPI but as a revenue engine.

The sale isn’t the end — it’s the beginning of the relationship.

The weakest link is the handoff between Sales and Service.

That’s why Blog #3 will introduce the Customer Connection Kit and NexGen Mobile App to close that gap.

Next Up: Blog #3 — “Bridging the Gap — How the Customer Connection Kit Transforms the Handoff Between Sales and Service.”